Still Life, Portraits, Urbex
Had a hard time letting the colors go in this one.. So why not post both?
Posted on 2012/06/10 at 04:42 in Architecture & Urbex | RSS feed
Particularly like the way the fire escape leads your eye through the colour version. Great image.
Thank you, Richard! I walked right passed it and did a double take. Usually scenes like these are drab, but the two colors of the doors and the escape really caught my attention.
I agree with Richard
Both are great but I prefer the B&W
Great Shot robert, this thime i prefer the colors.
Thank you, Geedebee! I think I’m still liking the color version also.
I love the color but have to admit I still love the way B&W seems so classic. Great photo, either way! Thanks for including them both. I liked seeing what your original photo looked like and the contrast between the two.
Thank you for your comment, Suzy. I’ve been thinking about posting both versions for a little while now, but usually one version wins out over the other. This time was a bit different!
If you look at my blog you’ll see I’m a bit of a b&w fan myself, so it comes with great reluctance that I have to admit I prefer the coloured job in this particular case. The black and white definitely simplifies the scene, as we would expect, but the complexity offered by the colours as well as the textures really does make this a multi-layered piece.
I’m sure you’ve played with the various twiddly bits in the conversion to black and white, but I’m wondering if a further tweak in contrast may worth looking at. cheers
Thank you for your comment, Stephen. I understand what you’re saying about the contrast in the b&w. For some reason, certain brick walls give me a harder time when toning than others. I actually did mess around with the levels, contrast, etc. but couldn’t really find a proper balance vs. the color one. I really think overall, the lighting could’ve been much better. Next time I’m down that way, I will try to time the shot a little better for later on in the day. That, and I really need to practice toning brickwork more.
I don’t know what tools you have available but ‘Channel Mixer’ is helpful in giving specific greys to specific colour – I have a older version of Photoshop, the latest versions seem to have a specifically good black and white conversion tool but I’ve no experience in using it.
Indeed, I’ve used the channel mixer but usually for a pseudo-infrared edit. TBH I haven’t tried it for outright toning. I may give that a shot and see what I can come up with. I usually do a majority of the b&w toning in camera raw or through the adjustment masks in photoshp. Thanks for the tip!
I also prefer the color version, in particular the first floor of the building!
Thank you, Nick.
It’s funny, when i saw the colour image I thought, what would that be like in monochrome? and there was the answer, think i prefer the colour one this time, seems to be a lack of the usuall tonal range in the monochrome shot,
Fully agreed – this is actually a photo from a few months ago that I’ve been tinkering around with since.. Still haven’t found that ‘sweet’ spot. Next time I’ll head there a bit later on in the day, hopefully get some better natural lighting to pop that texture out. Thanks for the comment, Russ!
I love the color image. I’m sure you just heard a lot of that now that I said it. your photo is beautiful
Thank you, Juneberrystar.
Unusually for me, I think I prefer the colour version
Hmm. All the black and white fans prefer the color version! B&W fail on my part, haha! Thanks for your comment, Rudolf!
prefer the colors
I like the name .. it is indeed like the game that I figure you are alluding to? The colour is good !!
Thank you, Helen, and indeed, it is a reference to that game. I don’t know why.. Perhaps it’s just the way the stairs flow, but it reminds me of it. In addition to the literal meaning, too. Thanks for your comment & visit.
Love the color,and name!
Thank you, Mary!
I definitly prefer the forst one. The colours are very great.
Thank you, Bente!
The colour definitely works better with this one.
Agreed! Thanks for your comment, CK.
I have the same issue sometimes deciding between colour and b&w and often end up posting both! Did that recently on my blog with “Ancient Artifact.” Great shot either way.
Great blog by the way!
Thanks, GreXon. Indeed, I think I may start doing that also. I usually try to finalize it before posting, but sometimes the decision isn’t that easy. Thanks for your comment and visit!
I like the color too on this one. Cool photo, fun title.
Thank you, Fork in My Eye! (love the name and avatar!) Your “Carolina Tiger Rescue” post was very cool to see.
Love the color one, love them both!
Thank you, Christina.
I love the colour image.
Thanks, braisedblue! Your photos are amazing!
Hate to go with the majority but, the color version is the clear winner here! No contest!
Yeah, I really think it was a b&w fail on my part, haha. I like the color version myself. Thank you for your comment!
I like the blue door, a bit of happy in a lonely, unloved place. Not really your dark & crumbling matter… Your other stuff, in comparison, this one feels like hope. Sorry for blah-ing.
Haha, what is blah-ing? I must know! I’m trying to get out of always posting the same thing. I don’t think I’d ever post something unbelievably cheery or something, but change is always good. Keeps me on my toes atleast. Thanks for your comment, Amy!
I like the colored one more… the composition is just brilliant
Thank you, 2 Rivers!
I’m usually loving your b&w, but the color, definitely on this one.
I’m with you, I think it’s more ‘flat’ than the color. Thanks for the comment, JBradshaw!
Yo tampoco se que con cual quedarme, las dos van estupendamente, saludos
Gracias Manoli! Quería que el blanco y negro a tener más textura. Pero tal vez la próxima vez.
I can’t decide which one I like better! ~Patty
I personally lean towards the color version. Thank you for your comment, and visit Patty!
I love everything about this, the subject, the composition and the way you processed it.
Thank you, SKEdazzles!
Both are beautiful, but I agree that the color version seems more engaging. Nice work!
Thank you, jheem!
Color wins on this one!
Thank you, Lois, and I agree! Could I also bother you for a link to your photography blog? I saw it the other day but my browser crashed before I could follow it!
Great! Thanks, Lois.
The color pops.
Agreed! Wanted the b&w texture to pop more, but it doesn’t. Thanks for the comment!
When looking at pics for writing prompts this contrast has a profound difference on the mood of the writing.
In a good way, I hope! Thanks for the comment and visit, Carl!
They look fantastic. But my preference is the colour version, the different coloured doors add a quirkiness that is really appealing
Thank you, Shell Shell, for your kind words and visit!
Love your title too.
I love the colour one.
Thank you, Jess!
Great composition. Brilliant title. Colour over B& W.
Thank you, John! I agree about the color also.
Beautiful! Maybe I love the color version a bit more I’m intrigued by the colored doors!
Thank you, Sil! I’m also partial to the color one, myself.
It almost looks like a scene from a sci-fi film! ♥
Hmm. Yeah, I can see that. Thank you for your comment and visit, PAZ!
I’ve enjoyed your blog and wish to honor you in my list of recommended sites, therefore; I have presented you with the Sunshine Award. Please see my blog entitled, Sunshine Award for more details.
Thank you very much, mypenandme, for the nomination. It’s very much appreciated!
Can you still get “Mousetrap” ? There’s a blast from the past, but it would be fun dropping the little ball in at the top of your picture and watching it bounce to the bottom.
Haha, agreed! I think you still can. It’s probably like monopoly with 1,290,384 variations.
Hi Robert, this is another example in your work of two worlds…….. both highly effective. I also love the slightly translucent feel that filtering can bring to an image. Masterful choice, selection, framing and handling.
I do love those colours..very unusual, almost like you have painted them on!
On this occasion the colour version works best for me. Love the mooted colours and the how the lighting enhances the compostion.
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:
You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )
Connecting to %s
Notify me of new posts via email.
Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.
Join 482 other followers